dec-2024-edition-1

Prologue

On Tuesday, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) made its latest policy decision, announcing a 25 basis points hike in the Monetary Policy Rate (MPR)—from 27.25% to 27.50%. This brings the MPR increases to a total of 875 basis points since Governor Olayemi Cardoso took office.

The recent modest appreciation of the Naira, moving from ₦1,750/₦1,755 per Dollar at the beginning of the week to ₦1,740/₦1,750 levels, suggests a slight strengthening of the currency in the parallel market. Despite the Federal Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) postings, there was an interbank liquidity deficit throughout the week.

Recent data released by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) reveals a positive trend in Nigeria’s economic performance, with Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growing to 3.46% year-on-year in the third quarter of 2024 (Q3 2024). This marks an improvement from the 3.19% recorded in the second quarter of 2024 (Q2 2024) and is also an increase from the 2.54% growth seen in Q3 2023.

Nigerian Financial Markets

Prior to the commencement of the MPC meeting, while some analysts had expected the rate to remain unchanged, others had anticipated a hike of between 25 and 50 basis points. The key decision by the MPC was to hike the MPR by 25 basis points, as all other parameters were maintained (the CRR (Cash Reserve Ratio) was kept at 50% for Deposit Money Banks (DMBs) and 16% for Merchant Banks; the Liquidity Ratio was maintained at 30%; Asymmetric Corridor, the difference between the CBN’s lending rate and its deposit rate, was kept at +500/-100 basis points). This gives the CBN flexibility to manage interest rates on either side of the corridor to address market volatility.

What Does This Mean for the Financial Markets?

The MPC’s decision to raise the MPR is clearly a further effort to control inflation and manage the impact of excess liquidity in the economy.

Despite several rate hikes over the past year, the FX market remains unstable, with the value of the Naira fluctuating significantly. The CBN has struggled to stabilise the Naira, and the hike in the MPR is seen as an attempt to attract more foreign investments. This could help alleviate some of the pressure on the FX market, as more capital inflows might provide a cushion to the Naira. However, the FX volatility remains a key issue that may continue to undermine the impact of such interventions.

It is imperative to point out that the latest decision of the MPC will lead to higher borrowing costs. As the MPR rises, businesses and consumers may find loans more expensive, which could impact spending and slow down economic activity. In the banking sector, the high CRR means that banks will continue to have less money to lend, which could affect their profitability. However, banks with strong liquidity positions might find opportunities in the bond market, where higher interest rates can yield better returns.

The actions by the MPC are ultimately designed to bring inflation under control. However, whether this will have the desired effect remains to be seen. If businesses pass on higher costs to consumers, inflation may remain high despite the rate hike. Similarly, if borrowing becomes more expensive, it could reduce consumer spending, which in turn might slow down economic growth.

In the foreign exchange market, the CBN’s interventions will likely continue to face challenges, particularly as foreign investors keep a close eye on the stability of the Naira. While the higher MPR could help to attract investment, the ongoing FX volatility remains a major risk for the economy.

Investor sentiment in the near-term is likely to be mixed. While higher interest rates typically attract foreign capital looking for better returns, the overall economic environment remains uncertain. High interest rates are often a signal of underlying economic challenges, and this might deter some investors who are concerned about the long-term health of the Nigerian economy. On the other hand, investors in government bonds and other fixed-income instruments might find the current environment more attractive as returns rise.

Going forward, the Naira’s appreciation may signal some stabilisation or improvement in investor sentiment, which could have positive implications for demand for bonds and other fixed-income securities. When the Naira strengthens, foreign investors may view it as a sign of reduced currency risk, making Nigerian bonds more attractive.

Some segments of the market have questioned the efficacy of MPR hikes considering the somewhat non-responsive stance in the yields on debt instruments. It is very likely that the 25 basis points hike was far less than expected and potentially priced-in by markets. It was astonishing for many, but logically prudent for the CBN to reverse the cap-volume on SDF placements by banks. This move, communicated via a circular on Friday is expected to neutralise the impact of the market’s disappointment with the extent of hiking.

There are some market participants who believe the last 50 basis points hike in MPR resulted in a 10% (approximately) devaluation of the Naira to $/₦1,700. We, however, are of the opinion that the devaluation, although coincided with the rate hike, was the effect of broader pressure on the currency (in some regards, seasonal) and had no direct correlation to the MPR hike. In fact, some schools of thought adduce that a higher MPR should translate to a revaluation of the currency (hence CBN’s adoption of the approach). In many regards, the correlation between the MPR and exchange rates is indirect, while there is a more direct symbiosis between the MPR and interest rates. In line with this, for each MPR hike, interest rates have followed suit, albeit delayed in some instances.

Nigeria’s GDP growth in Q3 2024 reflects a mixed, but optimistic outlook. The Services sector remains the dominant driver of growth, while the Agriculture sector continues to grow, albeit at a slower pace, and the oil sector shows incremental improvements. The strong performance of the Finance and Insurance sector also highlights the resilience of the economy. However, the challenges in oil production and agriculture still pose risks to long-term stability and diversification. Going forward, it will be crucial for Nigeria to continue promoting growth in sectors like Services, Finance, and Agriculture while addressing the challenges in the oil sector and ensuring that the economy remains buoyant in the face of global economic shifts.

As the year draws to a close, market participants are increasingly speculating about key developments and decisions that could lead to a significant decline in yields before the year ends. Several factors could influence this potential decline in yields. A positive movement in the foreign exchange market, like the Naira’s recent appreciation, might signal a more stable macroeconomic environment, prompting greater investor confidence and an increased appetite for fixed-income securities.

What Lies Ahead

The introduction of the Electronic Foreign Exchange Matching System (EFEMS) by the CBN has no doubt created some jittery sentiment amongst speculators as we have seen a significant boost to FX trading volumes in the last week. With tight implementation by the regulator, this could be a major win for Nigeria. We expect the local currency to appreciate in tandem this month.

CBN’s last-minute circular on Friday may have dashed many hopes that interest rates have peaked for the year 2024 as the impact of the SDF normalisation policy is a technical boost to the cost of funding, which will directly translate to lower appetite (particularly in an illiquid market). With the last bond auction for the year coming up, the Debt Management Office (DMO) may not be inclined to borrow heavily, especially given the high yields seen in previous auctions. The DMO might adopt a more conservative borrowing approach, considering that it has already raised substantial funds through the year at elevated rates, which could be sufficient to meet its financing needs. Given the high cost of borrowing, the government may look to limit new debt issuance to prevent further pressure on the budget and keep debt servicing manageable. To this end, while short-dated yields may certainly inch up significantly, a major uptick in bond yields cannot be guaranteed at this juncture.

Cryptocurrencies should continue to rally, although with cautious sentiment as inflation seems to re-emerge globally. We expect some more speculative short-selling as coins attain new highs.

In the absence of any major escalation in the Middle East or between Russia and Ukraine, oil prices should trade range-bound with a bearish squint.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *