It’s important to understand the difference between maladaptive perfectionism and a healthy quest for success. Maladaptive perfectionists see mistakes as unacceptable and believe failure makes them appear incompetent.
Those striving for excellence in a healthy way see mistakes as opportunities to learn and improve; they understand that failure is part of growth.
Having high standards can be positive, as goals motivate us to achieve great things. But when those goals are unrealistic or achievable only at great emotional cost, they can make it difficult to feel good about yourself. That’s when perfectionism becomes a problem.
In this series, we will explore the problematic side of perfectionism in four parts.
Today’s focus: Traits of a Perfectionist.
Traits of a Perfectionist
1. You’re always eager to please.
This often begins in childhood, the desire to please parents or teachers by earning that A+. Anything short of perfection feels like failure. Even a “B” can bring deep frustration or sadness. The longing to please becomes a quiet obsession.
2. Your drive for perfection is costing you, and you think it’s worth the price.
If you push yourself to unhealthy extremes to avoid being average or mediocre, believing “no pain, no gain” is the only path to success, you might be a perfectionist.
As Dr. David Burns notes, “The perfectionist acknowledges that his relentless standards are stressful and somewhat unreasonable but believes they drive him to excellence and productivity.”
3. You procrastinate.
Perfectionists are often chronic procrastinators…waiting for the “perfect” time, the “perfect” plan, or the “perfect” version of themselves before starting anything. But that time rarely comes.
The fear of failure, of not doing something perfectly, often leads to inaction.
4. You’re overly critical of others.
Perfectionists tend to project their high standards onto others. They can be rigid, judgmental, and difficult to please, like walking on eggshells around them.
In truth, they often reject in others what they secretly dislike in themselves.
5. You have an All-or-Nothing mindset.
“If I can’t do it perfectly, there’s no point in trying.” Perfectionists tend to think in extremes — success or failure, all or nothing. They’ll only take on tasks they feel sure they can master. If there’s a risk of imperfection, they often avoid it altogether.
6. You take everything personally.
Criticism or setbacks hit hard. Perfectionists often lack resilience, interpreting mistakes as proof of their deepest fear: “I’m not good enough.”
7. You get defensive when criticized.
At the slightest hint of criticism, a perfectionist may rush to defend themselves, even when it’s unnecessary. It’s a way of protecting their fragile self-image and avoiding anything that feels like a threat to their ego.
8. You’re never quite ‘there yet.’
Perfectionists are consumed by what they haven’t achieved. The goalpost keeps moving.
Because perfection is impossible, they’re trapped in a constant cycle of striving, never satisfied, never done.
9. Outcome-oriented, not process-oriented.
For perfectionists, joy lies only in the result, not in the journey. The process of learning or growing feels frustrating, not fulfilling.